Wine Advisor
Comte Georges de Vogue, Bonnes Mares Grand Cru 2005
View analysis
Description
Tasting notes
Reviewed by: Stephen Tanzer
Deep red-ruby. Superripe aromas of black plum, blueberry, graphite, mocha and wild herbs; there's something almost Bordeaux-like about this. Then dense, sweet and powerful, with a seamless, fine-grained texture and a richness verging on chocolatey. Less perfumed than the Chambolle cuvees, but with no shortage of sap. Most impressive today on the back end, finishing with substantial dusty tannins and rising flavors of plum, menthol and chocolate. This muscular and very young wine will be long-lived.
Reviewed by: Stephen Tanzer
Medium ruby-red. Briary blackberry, blueberry, violet and inky licorice on the nose. Thick on entry, then dense and sweet in the middle, with excellent thrust to the flavors of blackberry, violet, earth, herbs and spices. Finishes broad, subtle and long, with a powerful tannic backbone and lingering notes of dark berries, herbs and bitter chocolate. Built for extended aging.
Reviewed by: Neal Martin
A deep purple hue. The nose is very floral with violets and rose petals, mixed with cassis, blueberry jam and raspberry. Again great delineation – this is a joyous nose. The palate is more masculine than the Amoureuses with solid structure, more black fruits than red with an earthy undertow. This is a wine of the soil more than the air. Perhaps a little conservative towards the end: this will demand more time than is often afforded to Bonnes-Mares, but the persistency suggests it will be worth the wait. Drinking 2015-2025. Tasted January 2007.
Reviewed by: David Schildknecht
The 2005 Bonnes Mares marries black and red raspberries with fresh- sorbet- and liquer-like aspects alternating on a quite refined, polished, and (for this cru) seemingly less-savage than usual palate. Myriad herbs and spices mingle with the fruit and suggestions of wood smoke, horehound and sassafras emerge along with the sweet raspberries in a lingering finish that administers a considerable lashing of fine tannin and displays a sappy, resinous, faintly peppery cling. This is certainly the alter ego of this year’s cool, floral, tender Amoureuses. Final choices had been made as to those barrels from Musigny that would be culled to bottle as Chambolle 1er Cru but they represented several as yet unblended lots, which I was unable to taste. Francois Millet notes that skin-to-juice ratios this year were as formidably high as those of 2003, yet thanks to relatively mild temperatures, the fruit retained what he terms a “sorbet-like presentation.” Dreyfus Ashby, New York, NY; tel. (212) 818-0770 and a Peter Vezan Selection (various importers), Paris; fax 011 33 1 42 55 42 93
About the Producer
Domaine Comte Georges de Vogue is one of the most important estates in the Chambello-Musigny appellation, thanks to its stake in important vineyards. The Comte de Vogue is, as the English writer Charles Dickens once said, "as historic and admirable as a great mountain". The vineyard of the Comte de Vugo covers approximately 12.5 hectares, of which about 7 hectares are located in the Mussini vineyard (70% of the entire top vineyard) and about 2.5 hectares in the nearby Bernemar region. The grapes are all hand-harvested and the vast majority are destemmed (although in 1990 100% of the stems were retained). The wines are first fermented in vats, then aged for 18 months in small oak barrels (40% to 45% renewed), clarified with egg whites and lightly filtered before bottling. The wines are extremely intense and full-bodied, which is not surprising given the extremely low yields and the limestone soils of the Mussini vineyards. The wines of the Comtes de Vugo are not meant to be tasted young, and in outstanding vintages these very long-lived wines usually require 10 to 15 years of ageing. However, it is worth noting that the 2002 vintage of Musigny Old Vine is of particularly high quality. It has intense aromas of red cherry, spice and candied raspberry aromas, with a hint of oak. This noble, full-bodied, refined wine has fragrant floral flavours with fruity notes of red and black fruits. A more feminine wine than the bold, chewy, highly robust 1990 vintage, this is a work of art with delicate tannins.
1969(1)1978(1)1980(1)1985(2)1986(1)1987(1)1988(1)1989(1)1990(1)1991(1)1996(3)1997(1)1998(1)1999(3)2002(3)2004(2)
Package Size
